Episode 6.2 · 30 min

our synapsid ancestors and the end-Permian mass extinction

What did the synapsids that were not yet mammals reveal about the path toward our lineage—and how did that path survive the Great Dying? From the Karoo floodplains, this episode follows branching changes in teeth, jaws, palates and posture before reconstructing how Siberian Traps volcanism transformed land and sea through heat, oxygen loss and acidification. It also asks what Lystrosaurus and the disputed Karoo record reveal about survival.

Watch this film on YouTube ↗

Visual credits

35 sources

Sources and credits for imagery used in this film, including material incorporated into explanatory animations.

  • Iziko Diictodon Corkscrew

    Nkansahrexford

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Only the complete lateral crocodile skull with both open jaws and all visible teeth; exclude the human skull on the left. Preserve the full crocodile snout and jaw hinge. Materialize a tight standalone crop of this exact region, excluding neighboring panels and caption. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    קובץ על יד

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Iziko Sabre-toothed reptiles

    Nkansahrexford

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Madumabisa NHMUK PV R 37363 ventral

    The Trustees of the Natural History Museum, London

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Procynosuchus delaharpeae jaw

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Scientific figure · source page 1

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Gorynychus masyutinae

    Christian F. Kammerer

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Only the complete colored ventral Procynosuchus skull drawing at the top center, showing a long midline gap. Remove every neighboring fragment, letter, phylogenetic branch and caption. Keep the skull itself complete. IMPORTANT OUTPUT GEOMETRY: the crop tool expands your returned box by 0.015 of the WHOLE input page on each side. Locate the exact outer target region, then inset the returned box by 0.015 on each side (x0+0.015,y0+0.015,x1-0.015,y1-0.015), so tool expansion lands on the desired boundary. This is a one-page input: return page 1. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    Gigliotti et al. 2026

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Brocklehurst et al. 2025 Figure 1 showing synapsid humerus form and 3D anatomy used to compare forelimb function (cropped figure, PDF page 4)

    Brocklehurst et al. 2025

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Only the upper-left cat thermogram and its complete temperature scale. Remove the thin purple strip of the next panel at the bottom. Preserve the top and bottom scale numbers. IMPORTANT OUTPUT GEOMETRY: the crop tool expands your returned box by 0.015 of the WHOLE input page on each side. Locate the exact outer target region, then inset the returned box by 0.015 on each side (x0+0.015,y0+0.015,x1-0.015,y1-0.015), so tool expansion lands on the desired boundary. This is a one-page input: return page 1. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    yellowcloud from Germany

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Procynosuchus skull

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Permian Moschorhinus humerus cortex, Figure 5B

    Adam K. Huttenlocker and Jennifer Botha-Brink (2014)

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Glossopteris sp. (fossil leaf) (Permian; Antarctica) 2 (49062918518)

    James St. John

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Inostrancevia alexandrii skeleton 23

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Only the complete rectangular photograph labelled B, including the B and 10 cm scale. Remove the left strip of another panel, all white outer margins, and the bottom strip labelled D. IMPORTANT OUTPUT GEOMETRY: the crop tool expands your returned box by 0.015 of the WHOLE input page on each side. Locate the exact outer target region, then inset the returned box by 0.015 on each side (x0+0.015,y0+0.015,x1-0.015,y1-0.015), so tool expansion lands on the desired boundary. This is a one-page input: return page 1. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    Chen, Wu, Xie, Gao, Xiao and Tang (2024)

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Grand Canyon National Park- Brachiopod Fossils in Kaibab Limestone 0378 (7706182918)

    Grand Canyon National Park

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Yabeina globosa fusulinid foraminifera (Akasaka Limestone, Upper Permian; Kinshozan, Gifu, Honshu, Japan) 1 (46845445741)

    James St. John

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Native iron in basalt (Siberian Traps Flood Basalt, Permian-Triassic boundary times, 251 Ma; Putoran Plateau, Siberia, Russia) 2 (17338266745)

    James St. John

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Burgess, Muirhead and Bowring 2017 Figure 2 timeline of Siberian Traps magmatic stages relative to the end-Permian extinction interval (cropped figure, PDF page 3)

    Burgess, Muirhead and Bowring 2017

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Glossopteris fossil seed fern leaves in claystone (Illawarra Coal Measures, Upper Permian; Dunedoo area, New South Wales, Australia) (15448560516)

    James St. John

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Hill at Karoo National Park

    flowcomm

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Geology of Karoo Supergroup

    Oggmus

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Only the left-hand outcrop photograph panels a b and d, including their panel letters and original scale. Completely exclude the measured column and all plots to the right. The right border of the selected area is the vertical edge between the photo panels and white column area. Materialize a tight standalone crop of this exact region, excluding neighboring panels and caption. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    Gastaldo et al. (2020)

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Show only the UPPER measured stratigraphic-column portion: 70, 60 and 50 metre ticks, Katberg Formation label, the adjacent tan palynology strip, and the two complete upper lithology stacks. This is deliberately the upper section only, not the whole section. Desired final rectangle approximately [0.502,0.040,0.885,0.389]. Preserve this rectangle exactly after compensating tool padding. Completely exclude outcrop photos, all Hg plots, lower section, age labels and the lower stack beginning around y=0.394. IMPORTANT OUTPUT GEOMETRY: the crop tool expands your returned box by 0.015 of the WHOLE input page on each side. Locate the exact outer target region, then inset the returned box by 0.015 on each side (x0+0.015,y0+0.015,x1-0.015,y1-0.015), so tool expansion lands on the desired boundary. This is a one-page input: return page 1. (cropped figure, PDF page 1)

    Gastaldo et al. (2020)

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus georgi skeleton

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Iziko Thrinaxodon fossil

    Nkansahrexford

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus skull

    Ghedoghedo

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Proterosuchus fergusi skull, Iziko, SAM-PK-11208

    Nkansahrexford

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus declivis femur cortex, Figure 10A

    Jennifer Botha (2020)

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Iziko Diictodon Hibernating Pair

    Nkansahrexford

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus embryo Figure 1a: The actual NMQR 3636 fossil photograph. No preserved shell is implied.

    Benoit, Fernandez and Botha 2026

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus embryo Figure 1b: Segmented digital skeleton, not a photograph. Original 10 mm scale retained.

    Benoit, Fernandez and Botha 2026

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus embryo Figure 2d: NMQR 3636 only: anterior jaw model, black arrow and original 5 mm scale. Pair with the selected CT view in the same authored comparison.

    Benoit, Fernandez and Botha 2026

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus embryo Figure 2e: NMQR 3636 left CT section: open symphysis, dorsal direction and source annotations. No independent CT scale is invented; the 5 mm bar on the separate model applies to that model.

    Benoit, Fernandez and Botha 2026

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

  • Lystrosaurus embryo Figure 1c: Sophie Vrard artistic reconstruction; signature retained. Reconstructed skin and egg, not preserved evidence.

    Benoit, Fernandez and Botha (2026); artwork Sophie Vrard

    Incorporated into an explanatory animation; presentation may include cropping, labels and overlays.

Animation design references 1 sources

These works informed the design of explanatory animations. A reference listed here is not necessarily reproduced on screen.

Research references

Selected sources from the episode’s research and scientific figures.

  1. PLOS Biology paper ↗
  2. Gigliotti et al. 2026 ↗
  3. Huttenlocker et al. 2021 ↗
  4. Norton et al. 2023, craniodental correlates ↗
  5. Rawson et al. 2024 ↗
  6. 2021 fossil-record review ↗
  7. Bishop & Pierce 2024 ↗
  8. Rey et al. 2017, oxygen isotopes ↗
  9. Araújo et al. 2022, inner-ear biomechanics ↗
  10. Martinez et al. 2023, maxilloturbinals ↗
  11. Day et al. 2015 ↗
  12. 2023 Current Biology paper ↗
  13. Brant & Sidor 2024 ↗
  14. DOI: 10.1186/s13358-025-00348-7 ↗
  15. 2021 burrow study ↗
  16. Marine chronology ↗
  17. Primary paper ↗
  18. 2020 paper ↗
  19. Svensen and colleagues 2018 ↗
  20. Cui et al. 2021 ↗
  21. Penn, Deutsch, Payne & Sperling 2018 ↗
  22. Jurikova et al. 2020 ↗
  23. PubMed 42406958 ↗
  24. Joachimski et al. 2012 ↗
  25. 2023 mercury-isotope study ↗
  26. 2023 pollen-chemistry study ↗
  27. formal technical comment ↗
  28. response ↗
  29. Stanley 2016 ↗
  30. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-020-15243-7 ↗
  31. DOI: 10.1130/B35830.1 ↗
  32. DOI: 10.1130/B38563.1 ↗
  33. Primary paper ↗
  34. Fielding et al. 2019 ↗
  35. Wu et al. 2024 comparison ↗
  36. Chu 2025 ↗
  37. Primary paper ↗
  38. Open paper and downloadable supplementary datasets ↗
  39. Huttenlocker 2014 ↗
  40. Primary paper, *Did gorgonopsians survive the end-Permian extinction?* ↗
  41. EarthByte resource ↗
  42. Wang & Wang 2007 ↗
  43. Primary crinoid study and phylogenetic context ↗
  44. Primary paper ↗
  45. Chen & Benton 2012 ↗
  46. PLOS article ↗
  47. author-linked code deposit ↗
  48. ESA / Copernicus, Putorana Plateau, 2016 ↗
  49. NASA Earth Observatory, Early Snow on Russia's Putorana Plateau ↗
  50. IUGS Meishan geoheritage page ↗
  51. TimeScale Foundation Meishan photograph ↗
  52. Field evidence for coal combustion links the 252 Ma Siberian Traps with global carbon disruption ↗
  53. Roger Smith on the Permian mass extinction event ↗
  54. Brink & Reisz 2014 ↗
  55. Pusch et al. 2024 ↗
  56. Maho et al. 2024 ↗
  57. Endothiodon histology and CT study ↗
  58. Cox & Angielczyk's feeding-system study ↗
  59. Rawson et al. 2024 ↗
  60. data.bris deposit ↗
  61. Huttenlocker & Botha-Brink 2014, histology ↗
  62. Duhamel et al. 2026 ↗
  63. Bajdek et al. 2016, coprolites ↗
  64. Benton 2021 synthesis ↗
  65. Knaus et al. 2021, femoral blood supply ↗
  66. Newham et al. 2020, cementum and blood flow ↗
  67. Meiri & Levin 2022 ↗
  68. authors' reply ↗
  69. Bolton, Mangera & Benoit 2025 ↗
  70. Benoit et al. 2026 ↗
  71. https://quentinmartinez.fr/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Martinez_et_al_2023b.pdf ↗
  72. Day & Smith 2020, Endothiodon ↗
  73. Smith 2020, Cistecephalus ↗
  74. Viglietti 2020, Daptocephalus ↗
  75. Gastaldo and colleagues' 2020 climate-proxy study ↗
  76. Viglietti et al. 2017 ↗
  77. Smith and colleagues' 2021 study ↗
  78. Kammerer & Masyutin 2018 ↗
  79. Bulanov's 2024 Kotlassia distribution study ↗
  80. article deposit ↗
  81. Burgess & Bowring 2015 ↗
  82. 2025 review, The Anatomy and Lethality of the Siberian Traps Large Igneous Province ↗
  83. Grasby et al. 2011 ↗
  84. Augland et al. 2019 ↗
  85. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-026-74636-2 ↗
  86. Davydov 2021 ↗
  87. Callegaro et al. 2021 author manuscript ↗
  88. Zenodo model deposit ↗
  89. Sun et al. 2012, Lethally hot temperatures ↗
  90. Gliwa et al. 2022 ↗
  91. Brennecka et al. 2011 ↗
  92. Figshare 7357193 ↗
  93. Marquez et al. 2026 ↗
  94. GFZ's primary repository record ↗
  95. Sun et al. 2024 ↗
  96. https://historical-geobiology.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj25131/files/media/file/penn_2018_science_hypoxia_and_end-permian_extinction.pdf ↗
  97. Author/museum PDF ↗
  98. Paper and supplement ↗
  99. Paper, CC BY ↗
  100. supplement ↗
  101. research team's account ↗
  102. 2022 polar wood study ↗
  103. Published paper ↗
  104. author PDF ↗
  105. author bibliography ↗
  106. author-deposited abstract and supplement listing ↗
  107. Viglietti et al. 2022 Dryad deposit ↗
  108. Original paper ↗
  109. https://doi.org/10.1130/0016-7606(1996)108%3C0195:GCEPME%3E2.3.CO;2 ↗
  110. Galesaurus study ↗
  111. Kulik et al. 2021 ↗
  112. Primary histology study ↗
  113. Smith & Botha 2005 ↗
  114. author preprint deposit ↗
  115. PeerJ paper ↗
  116. DOI: 10.1038/srep24053 ↗
  117. Study ↗
  118. Sidor et al. 2013 basin comparison ↗
  119. S2 NMQR 3636 STL ↗
  120. S3 BP/1/9332 ↗
  121. S4 BP/1/4011 ↗
  122. Jasinoski & Abdala 2017 ↗
  123. directory and License.txt ↗
  124. Study ↗
  125. 2023 tectonic/climate study ↗
  126. 2017 terrestrial Permian review, repository PDF ↗
  127. 2023 diversification analysis ↗
  128. Smithsonian specimen context ↗
  129. 2025 fusuline study ↗
  130. Groves & Altiner 2005 ↗
  131. Clapham & Bottjer 2007 assemblages ↗
  132. 2024 Jiantianba study ↗
  133. Publisher record ↗
  134. 2024 regional sponge-reef synthesis ↗
  135. NPS Guadalupe Mountains reef ↗
  136. Carlsbad geology ↗
  137. Paper, especially Fig. 12 ↗
  138. Fig. 10 SVG/PNG ↗
  139. Fig. 1 PNG ↗
  140. S5 comparisons ↗
  141. Fig. 2 ↗
  142. Primary paper ↗
  143. Nanjing University Meishan context ↗
  144. Smithsonian collection object ↗
  145. Permian-Triassic Mayhem ↗
  146. U53A-08, Trouble Upstairs ↗
  147. The Karoo Basin ↗
  148. Siberian Traps ↗
  149. Large igneous provinces lecture ↗
  150. Oldest Dad fossil discussion ↗

Music

  • Meditation From The Star Orion
    OctahedronMusic · Envato Elements
Footage and image usage

Credits and usage times retained from the published edition or its production credit record. Where present, times identify visual appearances, not documentary chapters. Source and licence corrections are listed in the visual credits above.

  • Original animations and figures created by this channel.

How this film was made

Created and editorially directed by Anders Lunde using a custom production system developed over six months. AI assists research, drafting, programming, and visual production; I review and edit the material and make the final editorial decisions. Narration uses text-to-speech. Visuals combine custom-built scientific animations, AI-generated reconstructions, and credited scientific imagery.

Generated reconstructions illustrate scientific interpretations. They are distinct from photographs, specimens, and measured data.

More about the creator and production →